Tag Archive for 'Business'

Xero to Double Customer Numbers in Six Months

Today online accounting provider Xero announced they have added 1,000 customers over the last 50 days to take customer numbers to over 4,000. At this rate Xero are on track to double the 2,200 customers they had at 30 September 2008 by the end of their financial year (31 March 2009). The highlight of the announcement for me was the reporting of 1,000+ UK customers.

[Update: Xero have blown out my 4,000 figure announcing over 6,000 paying customers at 31 March 2009]

While impressive this is the growth rate required if Xero are to meet their target for the NZ market of 8,000 customers and break-even by May 2010. Xero still have some work to do to reach the estimated 12,000+ customers required to break-even. The estimated $2.6 million annualised revenue of their 4,000 customers (estimated revenue per customer $54 per month) will push back any possible requirement to raise additional capital. Current shareholders and potential investors will be looking forward to the release of the annual result later this year for an insight into revenue per customer, expenditure and balance sheet information.

Xero’s shares remain thinly traded (154,000 shares or $126,000 traded this year) with the share price of $0.75 representing a market capitalisation of $42 million. As I have stated previously Xero should be seen as a longer term investment (3 years +). Although the results to date have addressed some of the risks/uncertainties identified at the time of listing it is still early days for a company that aspires to be a global force in online accounting.

Conclusion

Great execution and result for the Xero team. This performance needs to be built on to meet projections, get to break-even and deliver the required return for investors.

Click here for a free trial of the “World’s easiest accounting system”

Disclosure: None

General Motors (GM) Runway: 350 Days

General Motors (GM) have just released another awful quarterly result announcing a $2.5 billion loss on revenues of $37.9 billion (down $5.8 billion on Q3 2007). Over the last quarter GM burnt nearly $50 million cash per day. Based on a 30 September balance of $16.2 billion in cash, marketable securities and readily available assets GM has approximately 350 days of runway. This back of the envelope calculation is typically reserved for startups not a 100 year old company with a 1/4 million employees.

The current global economic situation will have a significant impact on GM but it is an accelerant rather than the cause of GM’s current woes.

Despite growing revenues GM has lost market share to competitors such as Toyota.

Source: Reuters

Source: Reuters

GM and the US auto industry in general have failed to address the key issues (labour costs, product development and supply chain management) they are facing.

Source: Reuters

Source: Reuters

Resulting in the destruction of shareholder value:

Clusterstock provides a summary of GM’s CEO Rick Wagoner’s performance at the helm including losing $67 billion over 8 years.

GM are in the process of implementing a series of actions to improve their liquidity position by $20 billion by the end of 2009. Despite these steps there are calls for the US Government to step in and ensure GM does not have to file for bankruptcy. Based on the recent bailout of the financial sector, potential job losses and historic actions in the automotive industry it is unlikely GM will be allowed to fail without some type of intervention.

The issues faced by GM are not going to be solved by an injection of capital or tax payer gauranteed loans. Given the track record of the board and management team any bailout will only delay the inevitable bankruptcy, sell off or merger of the US’s largest auto company.

Xero - 2,200 customers, $1.4 million annualised revenue

New Zealand based online accounting software provider Xero has announced 2,200 customers at 30 September 2008. Assuming average revenue per customer of $54 this equates to annualised customer revenues of $1.4 million.

Xero is a ~2 year old software startup that bypassed the traditional venture capital funding path and raised $15 million in an IPO on the New Zealand Stock Exchange (NZX) in June last year. The disclosure requirements of being a listed company and Xero’s open approach to communications have provided an interesting insight into the mechanics of a startup.

Mainstream media have focused again on accounting profit numbers and meaningless % growth rates. Despite their relatively high media profile and listed status Xero is a startup company. When assessing the status of early stage companies the key metrics are customer/revenue growth (gross not just percentage), cash burn and cash position/runway.

Customer/Revenue Growth

In their prospectus Xero forecast 1,300 customers by 11 May 2008 and profitability within 3 years based on break-even at 8,000 customers. Xero achieved there first milestone with 1,406 customers in May this year and have continued their strong growth. Since listing Xero have revised their pricing structure ($75 per month reduced to $50 per month) increasing the number of customers required to break-even.

It is difficult to accurately predict Xero’s growth profile (but it will probably fit a S-curve). Given this uncertainty it is important to follow Xero’s information releases on customer numbers and understand the revenue implications. Based on the $54 average revenue per customer assumption each customer represents $650 revenue per annum. The focus over the next 12 months should be on whether New Zealand growth continues to accelerate and if Xero can gain traction in Australia and the UK.

Cash Burn

Monitoring cash burn is crucial for any company that has yet to reach profitability. It is perfectly acceptable for high growth companies to burn cash. Understanding the cash burn provides an insight into the breakeven point of the company and the potential future profitability. In the six months to 30 September Xero had operating expenses of $3.85 million ($7.7 million annualised). Based on an average revenue per customer of $54 per month Xero will need 12,000+ customers to break even (at the EBITDA line). This break even calculation is subject to the accounting treatment of development costs and does not include the $673k that Xero capitalised in the six months to 30 September. In the six months to 30 September Xero’s net cash position decreased $3.25 million.

Cash Position/Runway

Given that Xero has not yet reached profitability it is important to understand their cash position. At 30 September Xero had cash and cash equivalents of $6.3 million. Based on the current cash burn and annual revenues of $1.4 million (and growing) Xero appears to have sufficient funding to operate for the next 12 months (assuming no extraordinary increases in expenses). Looking beyond 12 months will depend on the level of customer growth and costs associated with expanding into new markets. There is a real possibility that Xero will need to raise additional capital in the next 2 years. This is a common practice for growing companies and to be expected for early stage enterprises.

Xero have achieved all of their stated targets since listing and have a growing base of paying customers. Over the next 12 months it will be interesting to observe how the ground work they have put in developing partnerships will translate into scalable customer growth. It will also be interesting to see how this model can be replicated in the larger Australian and UK markets.

Click here for a free trial of the “World’s easiest accounting system”

Previous commentary on Xero on Valuecruncher

Disclosure: None

Six Rules for Effective Forecasting

The Harvard Business Review (HBR) IdeaCast has an excellent interview with Silicon Valley forecaster Paul Saffo as a follow up to HBR article Six Rules for Effective Forecasting (premium content).

Paul Saffo’s Six Rules for Effective Forecasting

  1. Define a cone of uncertainty - Visualise the uncertainty and try to encompass all reasonable possibilities
  2. Look for the S curve - Everything interesting behaves like an S-Curve e.g. Moore’s law
  3. Embrace the things that don’t fit - These anomalies/discrepancies maybe subtle indicators of future changes.
  4. Hold strong opinions weakly - Draw quick conclusions and  then systematically dismantle them. Forecasting proceeds as a sequence of failed forecasts, be your own worst critic.
  5. Look back twice as far as you look forward - Identify patterns, history does not repeat but it may rhyme.
  6. Know when not to make a forecast - There are situations where the level of uncertainty precludes the ability to make any sort of meaningful forecast.

Saffo illustrates these rules with examples from technology including forecasting the emergence of the iPhone and global events such as the fall of the Berlin Wall.

Additional important points Saffo raises include:

  • Differentiating between effective and accurate forecasting
  • Embracing uncertainty
  • Use the past as illumination not support
  • Don’t cherry pick history to support your conclusions
  • “Never mistake a clear view for a short distance” new technology will take time to become an overnight success

Two rules that I think are important for forecasters are:

Check your ego at the door

As a forecaster you will be wrong more often than you are correct. It is important to acknowledge and learn from your mistakes rather than denying them or trying to explain mistakes away.

Transparency

Utilise a transparent framework and engage stakeholders. Transparency will allow you to learn from your forecasts and allow stakeholders to understand the context and limitations of the forecast.

The podcast is definitely worth listening to if you are interested in forecasting.